Lump Sum vs Annuity Calculator
This lump sum vs annuity calculator compares one payment now with a series of yearly payments, called an annuity, such as a lottery prize or a pension choice.
At a return of 5%, $50,000 a year for 20 years, with the first payment now, is worth $654,266.04 today.
No result. Fix the field with a message under it.
Your numbers
Starting values are examples. Change them to your own.
Result
At this return the payments are worth $654,266.04 today, $54,266.04 more than the lump sum of $600,000.00.
Today’s value of the payments
$654,266.04
- Lump sum
- $600,000.00
- Difference
- $54,266.04
- All payments added up
- $1,000,000.00
- Return at which the two are equal
- 6.18%
Today’s value of the payments
No result yet. Fix the field with a message under it, and the numbers will appear.
What to check next
- What if the payments never ended?
See the value of the same yearly payment going on without end.
- What will the payments buy in later years?
See how rising prices shrink what a fixed amount buys.
How to read the comparison
The payments are turned into one value today, using the return you think you could earn on the lump sum. Then the two can be compared directly.
The break-even return is the return at which the two are worth the same. If you would earn more than that, the lump sum comes out ahead. If you would earn less, the payments do.
Money is not the only factor. Payments give a steady income and protect against spending too fast; a lump sum gives more control.
What this does not include
- Taxes, which can differ a lot between the two choices.
- Payments that rise each year.
- The risk that a payer cannot keep paying.
Examples
Sample inputs, not offers.
| Yearly return you could earn | Today’s value of the payments |
|---|---|
| 2% | $833,923.10 |
| 3% | $766,189.96 |
| 4% | $706,696.97 |
| 5% | $654,266.04 |
Other inputs stay as in the example above: Lump sum now $600,000, Payment each year $50,000, Years of payments 20 years, When each payment is made First payment now.
How this is calculated
Today’s value of the payments = payment × (1 − (1 + r)−n) ÷ r, with r the yearly return and n the years. If the first payment is now, it is multiplied by (1 + r). At a 0% return it is payment × years.
The break-even return is the rate at which that value equals the lump sum. We find it by narrowing the range step by step. When there is none, for example when the payments add up to no more than the lump sum, the page leaves that row out.
We checked today’s value of the payments and the return at which the two are equal against a widely used finance program written by others (numpy-financial 1.1.0).
This calculator uses only the numbers you type and fixed formulas. There are no outside figures to cite.
Reviewed
Questions
What return should I type?
A return you could really expect on the lump sum after fees. Try a low and a high figure to see both sides.
Does tax change the answer?
It can. This page leaves taxes out, and the two choices are often taxed differently. Ask a tax professional before you decide.
What if the payments rise each year?
This page uses equal payments. A rising payment is worth more than the value shown.
This is an estimate for general information, not financial or tax advice. The terms of your offer decide what you receive.